Pizza doesn’t have to be cooked in a wood-fired oven for it to be tasty, especially frozen pizza. When you use a toaster oven or air fryer to cook pizza the results will surprise you. Plus, toaster ovens aren’t as big as full-size ovens, so they’re suitable for small kitchens.
Unfortunately, finding the best toaster oven for pizza is easier said than done. The good news is that we’re here to help. We’ll take you through the best toaster ovens and show you what to look for to help you narrow down your options.
Read on to learn more below.
DISCLOSURE: This post may contain affiliate links, meaning when you click the links and make a purchase, we receive a commission at no extra cost to you.
Features to Consider When Shopping for Toaster Ovens for Pizza
When you’re shopping for a pizza oven you need to make sure it has the right specifications. Otherwise, you’ll struggle to cook pizza. Some notable features to look for include the cooking temperatures, size, type of oven, and extra accessories.
Cooking Temperature
The first thing to look for is the cooking temperature. Make sure the temperature controls fall within a range that’s appropriate for you. Many traditional toaster ovens have a temperature range between 150°F and 450°F.
It’s important to note that air fryers are different when it comes to temperature. Most air fryers have temperature ranges between 325°F and 450°F. For this reason, you have less flexibility at times with air fryers.
Size and Space
Size and space are important when you’re shopping for any type of pizza oven. When you have a small kitchen, you’ll want a compact toaster oven that doesn’t take up your whole countertop. On the other hand, bigger kitchens can accommodate large toaster ovens and more kitchen appliances.
When it comes to the space of a toaster oven, we’re referring to its capacity. Larger toaster ovens like June ovens can cook a whole chicken. However, more compact toaster ovens will only cook a few slices of pizza at a time. Depending on who you’re cooking for, size matters here.
The Type of Oven
The type of oven is also important. You want to consider the type of heating element and its overall design. For example, there are key differences between air fryers and toaster ovens but both will cook pizza.
Traditional toaster ovens have a slower cooking time and don’t reach temperatures as high as an air fryer. Therefore, they’re better for cooking pizza over long periods and other meals like chicken breast.
On the other hand, air fryers have faster cooking times but share many features, like slow cooking, with toaster ovens. Air fryers may also come with unique features like air fryer baskets. An air fryer typically also has fewer temperature settings than a toaster oven, which reduces flexibility.
Air fryers are also better for cooking meals like chicken wings, french fries, and open-faced sandwiches.
While this may seem overwhelming we have some good news. The majority of the best toaster ovens for pizza are typically a combination between air fryers and toaster ovens. So, you get the best of both worlds.
Rack Positions
Rack positions are also important to consider, especially for toaster ovens. Like a traditional oven, toaster ovens have a few different rack positions. Compact toaster ovens will have one or two positions, while larger toaster ovens will have three or more.
The bottom two rack positions are for pizza and bread, while the top rack position is typically for broiling. Both options are viable depending on your needs and what you’re looking to cook.
If you want to cook things like chicken breasts or chocolate chip cookies, it’s best to have a versatile toaster oven. Being more flexible gives you more opportunities to cook things like open-faced sandwiches alongside your frozen pizza.
Extra Accessories
Extra accessories are also important. Accessories give you more flexibility and may even help you make a better pizza. Plus, with the right extra accessories you can replace some of your other kitchen appliances.
Some extra accessories to look for include the following:
- Extra racks
- Baskets for broiling
- Removable crumb tray
- The ability to remove racks to create space
- Digital controls
- Smart features
Some of these features may not be necessary for some but crucial to others. For example, you’ll struggle to cook chicken wings in a toaster oven without a broiling basket.
Our Top Picks for the Best Toaster Ovens for Pizza
Once you know what to look for, it’s easier to find the best toaster ovens for pizza. We take you through our top picks for countertop pizza ovens below.
1. Breville Smart Oven Pro
The Breville Smart Oven Pro is a compact oven with a brushed stainless steel design. It’s a good-looking home appliance that also packs a punch with its Element Iq system. The system reduces cooking time by 30% and uses smart technology to eliminate cold spots.
The Breville Smart Oven Pro also comes with an impressive capacity. Cook up to six whole slices of bread, 13-inch pizzas, and much more. Its smart settings and baking pan also make it effective for baked goods.
Other notable features include the LCD digit display, smart temperature controls, and an even light. All of these features make it one of the best toaster ovens for pizza on the market.
Pros
- LCD digital display
- Smart technology helps with temperature settings, and cooking times, and removes cold spots
- Fits in dorm rooms
- 10 cooking functions.
- Interior oven light
Cons
- Not suitable for people who prefer the knob temperature settings found on traditional toaster ovens
2. Breville Compact Smart Toaster Oven
Breville is one of the best in the kitchen appliance game when it comes to toaster ovens. It combines Element Iq smart technology to adjust cooking settings, temperature settings, and reduce cold spots. The smart technology is also easy to control with its digital LCD.
When it comes to cooking pizza you have several settings to choose from and a pizza setting. The Breville Compact Smart Toaster Oven uses four independent quartz heating elements to get an even cook. These heating elements are simple to control with eight cooking options on the LCD screen.
The Breville Compact Smart Toaster Oven is small enough for small kitchens, dorm rooms, and easy to store. Overall, Breville toaster ovens are some of the best products on the market for pizza and other foods.
Pros
- Interior light
- Four heating elements and smart settings reduce cold spots
- LCD screen and temperature controls
- Compact design
- Easy reach
Cons
- Lacks some cooking settings that more expensive Breville toaster ovens come with
3. Breville BOV800XL Smart Oven
Breville toaster ovens are known for being the best in the industry. The Breville BOV800XL Smart Oven doesn’t disappoint with its 9 cooking settings, generous capacity, and five quartz heating elements. Furthermore, it looks good with a brushed stainless steel design that makes you want to keep it on the countertop.
What sets this toaster oven apart, though, is its convection capabilities. It will reduce cooking times by up to 30% and cooks pizza, baked goods, french fries, and even chicken breast. Ultimately, you can use it as a true countertop oven.
Many people also use the Breville BOV800XL Smart Oven as a replacement for regular ovens. This is especially true in small kitchens or apartments that don’t have an oven.
Pros
- Uses convection to reduce cooking times by 30%
- Beautiful stainless steel design
- Can replace regular ovens
- 5 heating elements reduce cold spots
- 9 cooking settings
Cons
- Doesn’t have 10 cooking settings like some larger Breville toaster ovens
4. Hamilton Beach 6-Slice Countertop Toaster Oven
Hamilton Beach is known for being an industry leader when manufacturing kitchen appliances. The Hamilton Beach 6-Slice Countertop Toaster Oven is no different. It can hold six whole slices of bread, cook a whole chicken, pizza, and much more.
Hamilton Beach also added some quality-of-life features to this toaster oven. It comes with a roll-top door, two rack positions, and contoured temperature control knobs. These features enhance its ease of use.
Another unique aspect of this Hamilton Beach product is its compact design. It’s much smaller than other toaster ovens, which makes it easy to use in small kitchens or apartments.
Pros
- Compact design
- Roll-top door
- Multiple rack positions
- Removable crumb tray
- Big temperature range of 150°F to 450°F
Cons
- No digital controls
- No LCD screen
- No smart features
5. Nuwave Bravo XL Air Fryer Toaster Smart Oven
The Nuwave Bravo XL Air Fryer Toaster Smart Oven is one of the best kitchen appliances around. It’s powerful enough to replace your regular oven and you can even use griddles with it. For these reasons, it’s known as a 12-in-1 toaster, oven, and air fryer.
The Nuwave Bravo XL Air Fryer Toaster Smart Oven uses digital controls to help you customize your cooking settings. The linear thermal technology reduces cold spots by adjusting the temperature and it reaches between 5°F and 450°F. When it comes to temperature range, it’s one of the widest ones on the market.
Nuwave Bravo toaster ovens also have digital thermometers that measure the internal temperature of the oven. You’ll also find up to 112 preset options.
Pros
- Great for roasted vegetables
- Internal digital thermometer
- Interior light
- Wide temperature range
- Linear thermal technology
- Can fit a whole chicken
Cons
- Expensive
- Too large for some small kitchens
6). Cosori Smart 12-in-1 Air Fryer Toaster Oven Combo
The Cosori Smart 12-in-1 Air Fryer Toaster Oven Combo will cook pizza, a whole chicken, or even an open-faced sandwich. While its capacity and cooking options are impressive, it also has smart technology and companion applications. Examples include Cosori recipe videos, wifi capabilities, and much more.
When it comes to cooking settings this Cosori smart toaster oven won’t disappoint. The LCD screen and digital display make it easy to choose between its 12 cooking functions. Asa bonus, you can make baked goods like chocolate chip cookies with a baking pan.
The Cosori Smart 12-in-1 Air Fryer Toaster Oven Combo also comes with a convection fan. Convection fans amplify convection currents to reduce cold spots and uneven temperatures.
Pros
- LCD screen
- Cooks anything from pizza to chocolate chip cookies
- Large capacity
- Makes a crispy crust with its convection fan
- Better than many standard ovens
Cons
- Expensive
7). Oster Air Fryer Oven
The Oster Air Fryer Oven has a large capacity and plenty of cooking settings. Whether you bake cookies or plan on feeding people with a whole chicken, you can do it. This is supported by its 10 cooking settings, flexible control panel, and strong heating elements.
These features are great but what makes this air fryer unique is its capacity and doors. It comes with French doors that open with one single pull. These glass doors make it easy to see the progress of your meal, especially combined with the interior light.
The Oster Air Fryer Oven also preheats faster than similar products. It preheats 35% faster than other toaster ovens and 50% faster than standard ovens.
Pros
- Elegant French glass doors
- Several rack options
- Extra large capacity
- Digital control panel
- Faster preheating
Cons
- Expensive
- Too large for small kitchens or dorm rooms
8). Elite Gourmet ETO-4510M
The Elite Gourmet ETO-4510M is the definition of elite when it comes to making pizza. It’s a countertop oven that will fit up to 18 whole slices of bread, two 9-inch pizzas, and chicken wings. Furthermore, its extra large capacity makes it suitable for cooking a whole chicken or larger 14-inch pizza.
The Elite Gourmet ETO-4510M also uses independent temperature knobs and has a temperature range of 450°F. The high heat is combined with stainless steel grates for a smooth cooking experience. It also comes with a baking pan, wire racks, a rotisserie prod, and a tray removal tool.
These features make it simple to cook or even bake cookies. Overall, it’s one of the largest products on the market.
Pros
- French glass doors
- Stainless steel racks
- Lots of additional accessories
- Wide temperature range
Cons
- No digital controls
- Lacks an LCD screen
9). Galanz Large 6-Slice True Convection Toaster Oven
The Galanz Large 6-Slice True Convection Toaster Oven is beautiful. It’s one of the nicest-looking home appliances you’ll find with its retro blue appearance. The style of this oven is also enhanced by the glass door and interior light.
When it comes to cooking the Galanz Large 6-Slice True Convection Toaster Oven is efficient. It fits 12-inch pizzas, up to six slices of toast, and you can even bake cookies. To maximize your cooking experience it also comes with temperature control knobs and 8 cooking settings.
Unlike many basic air fryers, this toaster oven also has a wide temperature range. Choose between 250°F and 400°F.
Pros
- Great ease of use with temperature control knobs
- Retro blue design
- Glass door
- Interior lights
Cons
- No digital display
- No LCD screen
10). Black+Decker 8-Slice Extra Wide Convection Countertop Toaster Oven
The Black+Decker 8-Slice Extra Wide Convection Countertop Toaster Oven is a well-rounded machine. It’s for professional chefs or beginners with its temperature control knobs. There are also several presets to help you cook pizza or bake cookies.
That said, what makes this toaster oven unique is its capacity-to-size ratio. Its small size makes it compact but it still fits up to 9 whole slices of bread. Additionally, you’ll have plenty of space to cook pizza, hash browns, and chicken breast.
The Black+Decker 8-Slice Extra Wide Convection Countertop Toaster Oven also fits most oven pans. Therefore, you can use your favorite cookware with this countertop oven.
Pros
- Several cooking settings
- 60-minute timer
- Fits most oven pans
- Comes with a baking pan
- Wide temperature range
Cons
- No digital display
- Lacks smart features
11). Hamilton Beach Countertop Oven and Pizza Maker
Hamilton Beach typically makes compact countertop ovens. While this Hamilton Beach product is also compact, it has the capacity for 4 whole slices of bread. It’s also a good-looking toaster oven that has a stainless steel finish and a glass door.
As for the specs, the Hamilton Beach Countertop Oven and Pizza Maker is great for its size. It reaches several temperatures with a maximum temperature that’s comparable to full-size ovens. Additionally, Hamilton Beach includes knobs that are easy to use to control the temperature in several intervals.
Hamilton Beach also has a few more tricks up its sleeve when it comes to energy. For example, it uses 75% more energy than full-size ovens. Plus, it heats up more than 25% faster.
Pros
- 25% faster and 75% more energy-efficient than conventional ovens
- Compact design with a large capacity for a 9-inch pizza
- Glass doors
- The wire rack is included
Cons
- Only a few times settings and cooking settings
12). Instant Omni Plus
The Instant Omni Plus is one of the most advanced countertop ovens around. It fits several 9-inch slices of pizza, 6 pieces of toast, and even a whole chicken. While it’s one of the larger countertop ovens, its sleek black finish matches most kitchen themes.
The Instant Omni Plus is also one of the best when it comes to ease of use. Its digital display makes it easy to find all of the cooking and temperature settings. As for the screen, it’s an LCD screen that shows you the cooking time and much more.
Instant Omni Plus added some safety features too. It has an auto shut-off feature and projections for overheating.
Pros
- Safety features like overheating protection and auto shut-off
- Suitable replacement for a standard oven
- Wide temperature range
- Digital display on an LCD screen
Cons
- Expensive
- Hard to store
- The black finish scuffs and shows fingerprints
13). KitchenAid KCO211BM Digital Countertop Toaster Oven
KitchenAid is known for making great kitchen appliances like mixers but they also make a toaster oven. The KitchenAid KCO211BM Digital Countertop Toaster Oven is perfect for cooking pizza, chicken wings, and more. To help you cook it has 9 settings to choose from and plenty of accessories like a baking pan.
KitchenAid also made an oven that looks nice. The black finish paired with the glass door helps it look nice on any countertop. Its large capacity also makes it a Countertop oven that’s on par with regular ovens.
Another benefit of this KitchenAid toaster is its digital display. The LCD screen gives you your cooking time and temperature readings.
Pros
- LCD screen
- Temperature control knobs increase the ease of use
- Large capacity can fit a whole chicken
- Gorgeous black finish and glass doors
Cons
- Doesn’t heat up as fast as air fryer and toaster oven combos
- Expensive for its design
14). Panasonic Toaster Oven FlashXpress
The Panasonic Toaster Oven FlashXpress uses infrared technology to cook food. Infrared technology makes it easier to cook pizza evenly because there are no cold spots. To maximize the infrared technology Panasonic gives you 9 cooking settings.
Panasonic also knows how to make a device that looks good on kitchen countertops. It has a glass door and interior light that’s surrounded by a silver finish. Ultimately, it looks shiny and nice and fits in with most stainless steel appliances.
Panasonic doesn’t leave you hanging on the extra accessories either. It comes with a baking pan, safety features, and an LCD display for cooking times.
Pros
- LCD screen for cooking times
- Comes with safety features to prevent injury and fires
- Compact design
- Interior light
- Glass door
Cons
- Only comes with a few additional accessories compared to other toaster ovens
15). Ninja SP201 Digital Air Fry Pro
The Ninja SP201 Digital Air Fry Pro is an 8-in-1 function toaster oven. It can do all kinds of things in this little device, including dehydrating your foods!
You can cook your foods up to 60% faster than a traditional oven and with 75% less fat than traditional frying. All of this with technology that allows for precision controlled-temperature and optimum cooking temperature.
Even better news, while this toaster oven is considered high capacity (it can cook a 13″ pizza and a 2-lb roast), it takes up very little counter space when you store it by flipping it up and against your backsplash.
Pros
- Precision heat control
- Stores upright to take up less counter-space
- XL capacity
- Controls are easy to read and use
- Has an interior light
Cons
- Dishwashing trays and baskets can warp them
- Crumbs can get stuck in the back
Final Thoughts
Frozen pizza doesn’t have to be a soggy microwaved mess, even if you have a small kitchen. With the best toaster ovens for pizza, it’s easy to efficiently cook pizza on your kitchen countertops. That said, it’s important to choose the pizza oven that suits your needs.
Always consider features that are important to you. For example, some shoppers prefer a traditional toaster oven, while others prefer digital toaster ovens. Overall, every option we’ve covered is a suitable toaster oven for cooking pizza.
Want more tips for making pizza in your home? Check out some of our other articles below:
- Best Electric Pizza Ovens
- Best Indoor Pizza Ovens
- Best Countertop Pizza Ovens
- Best Pizza Maker Machines
- Best Mixers for Making Pizza Dough
As someone from Long Island, New York, Thomas knows what it takes to make a good pizza. He understands that it’s a combination of high-quality ingredients, well-rounded pizza ovens, and a little bit of love. From the dough of a Neapolitan-style pizza to the wood that powers a wood-fired pizza oven, he has you covered. Thomas’ love of pizza is what got him here and he hopes that you’ll enjoy pizza as much as he does soon.
