Skip to content

Best Pizza Maker Machines (Complete Guide 2023)

best pizza maker machines complete guide

From my view, there is nothing better than enjoying a delicious homemade pizza! For years, making homemade pizza required a level of expertise that was better left to professionals. Now, with a pizza maker machine, you can, indeed, enjoy delicious pizza from the comfort of your own home without commercial cookware.

If you don’t already own one of these, there’s no time like the present to invest. A good-quality pizza maker product can be a great addition to any home kitchen. Your favorite part will be that you get to enjoy fresh, hot pizza, and all kinds of food these machines can prepare right in your home! There’s no human activate or “activate and hold” button, you don’t have to hold the button down, and no need to push the button to confirm. No filter is required. No grill to fire up, no wood to haul, no ovens to make your home full of hot air. These machines are so smart on their own and remove the guesswork, you could almost think a robot or human is magically operating their parts without your help. Almost as easy as using a toaster! You can enjoyably spend an hour or two of your time using these!

If you want to shop for the best pizza maker machines without taking the time and days to research the information, this guide has you covered with reviews that source the product and information right in the comfort of your own home! Let’s view everything you need to know about pizza makers and explore our top picks for the top makers out there. 

DISCLOSURE: This post may contain affiliate links, meaning when you click the links and make a purchase, we receive a commission at no extra cost to you.

What Should You Consider? Pizza Maker vs Outdoor Pizza Oven

Before you buy a pizza maker product, consider where and how you want to use one. 

Some pizza cookers are meant for making outdoor pizzas. This is usually a gas or multi-fuel pizza oven, installed into backyards that take time to get fired up. There are also indoor varieties, designed to fit on countertops for kitchen use. Both are great options if you want to start cooking pizzas at home! It all comes down to personal preference and storage space. 

Size and Weight: Which Pizza Maker to Shop For?

The size of your pizza making kitchen appliance will determine what size pizzas you will be able to cook. Think about how many people you need to feed on pizza night. If you’re feeding a large family, then the bigger the better! If you’re cooking for just yourself and one other person, a smaller model will work perfectly. 

A smaller pizza cooker is also better for portability, as they’re lighter in weight. With a small, lightweight pizza maker, you can take your device throughout your home. A heavier appliance, though, will do better to be permanently housed in your kitchen or outdoors. 

Temperature: Which Pizza Maker Puts Out the Best Heat?

For pizzeria pizza, invest in a machine that will reach high temperatures. Pizza is meant to cook at high temperatures, especially if you want a crispy pizza. Look for a pizza making machine with a heating element that can get hot, fast. This will allow you to easily cook your pizza dough, and any other foods you want to warm with your machine.

Surface Quality

Many are made of non-stick coatings, which accounts for cleanup being easier and more convenient. 

Try to look for one with a non-stick coating that will require less oil as a lubricant. If the oven is not nonstick, be sure you’re always using oil of some kind on your dough.

Flip or Dual Sided Feature

A flip or dual side feature can help you make a perfect pizza, every time. This feature means the pizza maker will cook the pizza from both the top and bottom creating a quicker cook. It also allows for an even distribution.

Our Top Picks for the Best Pizza Maker Machines

PRODUCT DETAILS
  • Comes with a removable non-stick pan.
  • Creates a variety of foods like frozen appetizers.
  • Make a 12” pizza in 15 minutes.
Check Price on
Amazon.com
  • Joy of Homemade Pizza.
  • Makers Gonna Make.
  • Oven-Free & Indoor.
Check Price on
Amazon.com
  • Bakes 12 Inch Pizzas.
  • Perfect For Quesadillas.
  • Opens 180 degree .
Check Price on
Amazon.com

Best Overall: Presto Rotating Pizzazz Pizza Maker

Presto is the maker of a very innovative electric pizza making machine with a small footprint. This machine can cook a frozen pizza or fresh pizza perfectly! The rotating tray ensures even baking, plus the top/bottom heating elements will bake your pizza evenly from both sides.

The heating elements are controlled separately which allows people to select the bottom, top, or both elements for perfect, individualized results. When finished, a timer will sound, and the heating elements automatically turn off saving you money. 

Pros

  • Saves 60% in energy over an oven
  • Comes with a removable non-stick pan
  • Creates a variety of foods like frozen appetizers, chicken wings, chicken nuggets, quesadillas, and more.
  • Make a 12” pizza in 15 minutes

Cons

  • Not for outdoor use
  • Need to unplug product after each use
  • Comes with a removable non-stick pan.
  • Creates a variety of foods like frozen appetizers.
  • Make a 12” pizza in 15 minutes.
Check Price on
Amazon.com

Best Runner Up: Betty Crocker Pizza Maker

This maker is 12″ and contains a non-stick surface making clean up easy and efficient. It is also made of stainless steel, thereby making it durable and long-lasting. It has the versatility like the others to cook a variety of foods, including baked goods. 

Pros

  • Energy efficient
  • Power on indicator and ready to bake light
  • Self-regulated thermostat
  • Floating hinge and dual heat lid/base easily create frittatas and giant cookies
  • Easy to store with cord wrap

Cons

  • It may not get hot enough for some frozen pizzas
  • Some users suggest running it for a while prior to cooking food as it releases a chemical smell. 
  • Joy of Homemade Pizza.
  • Makers Gonna Make.
  • Oven-Free & Indoor.
Check Price on
Amazon.com

Best Budget: Courant Pizza Maker

This pizza maker has all the features that you could want. This 12” cooker can cook different foods like quesadillas and appetizers, in addition to pizza, making it very versatile. If you want a crispy crust maker, this is the machine for you, as it heats up quickly and efficiently.

Its self-regulated thermostat ensures that the pizza is perfectly baked each time. With a ready-to-cook and power indicator light to view, it makes cooking convenient. 

Pros

  • Easy storage and non-stick plates make it easy to clean
  • Available in red and black
  • Aluminum material makes it lightweight

Cons

  • Not as durable
  • Not the most desirable heat distribution
  • Bakes 12 Inch Pizzas.
  • Perfect For Quesadillas.
  • Opens 180 degree .
Check Price on
Amazon.com

Best Professional Pizza Maker: Breville Pizza Maker

Breville makes the top pizza making machine in this category. This pizza making machine will give you a crispy crust and provide results similar to a brick oven. It has a ceramic pizza stone that cooks pizzas evenly and will allow you to cook with higher temperatures as it retains well.

It has two heating elements found on the top and bottom, and comes with a temperature adjuster located on the upper lid. This will allow you to control the setting on the crust for perfect results. 

Pros

  • Temperature goes up to 660° F
  • Crust settings are in thin, medium, and thick
  • Provides excellent flavor

Cons

  • Pizzas with a great deal of toppings may get stuck to the burner
  • No timer
  • Countertop pizza maker.
  • Dual heating elements on the top and bottom.
  • Settings for thin, medium and thick crusts.
Check Price on
Amazon.com

How to Use A Pizza Maker

Prior to cooking, allow your appliance to run for ten minutes keeping the lid closed. This will allow the lubricant to burn off and will pre-season a cooking stone. Don’t use cooking oil or water when cooking, cleaning, or seasoning the pizza maker. If it uses cooking stones, an uncooked pizza will need to be placed on the stone’s surface.

Some tips include:

  • Don’t use a knife or pizza cutter on a cooking stone
  • To cook a frozen pizza, allow the bottom to thaw prior to using the machine. It will give you a crispier crust.
  • Turn your peel for even cookinghttps://www.goodlifepizzaovens.com/essential-pizza-oven-accessories/

To cook using an electric pizza maker, plug the machine in and turn it on. Make sure you know what the desired temperature is to cook your pizza since all varieties require different temperatures. Once the ideal temperature is reached, wait until the pizza is fully baked. On many models, a timer will let you know once it is cooked.

Allow it to cook for two to five minutes after removing it. 

Always consult with the instructions on your pizza making machine. This will provide you with all the information you require to increase the longevity of the machine.